If CAPE were well-designed, the algorithm would be time-weighted, and there would be no “quirk” caused by weighting 10-year-old information the same as current information.
Not time-weighting is either a curve-fit tell, or an opportunity to improve the CAPE concept.
There's an odd quirk to the CAPE Ratio. Since it's based on 10 years, we're currently dropping the terrible earnings from 10 years ago. Hence the earnings lining (red) is rising. Blue is regular earning and black is the S&P 500.