Well, you have to hand it to James Lindsey - he "got us."
He was playing to get a headline - "American Reformer Publishes Communist Manifesto" and he got it. Never mind that the entire thing was care-takingly rewritten, substantively inverted, and re-packaged into a passable right-wing article. If our enemies keep working at their craft and presenting even more convincing hoaxes, they'll put us out of a job.
The truth is that American Reformer, the little journal that James' calls a "leading publication," the "flagship," and the "more respectable, mainstream wing" of his made-up term the "Woke Right" has grown by leaps and bounds in the last few years under the direction of a lean editorial team.
American Reformer's mission is to reinvigorate the Protestant Church for the cultural challenges of our day, rooted in the rich tradition of Protestant social and political thought. James has resented us from the beginning because he knows that we - unlike him - have more satisfying answers than "we just need to return the classical liberalism of the 1990s!" We are re-examining the faulty assumptions that have brought American society to its current state, and recovering wisdom from across millennia that can be a solace and a guide in wild political times.
American Reformer has always prided itself on giving a shot to less established authors. We've published hundreds of these over the last few years, many of whom have grown into leading voices at the nexus of American Christianity and politics/culture. We undeniably have significant energy and growth on our side. And we are almost alone amongst major Christian outlets to unabashedly support Trump's agenda and to have standing in the emerging coalition between MAGA, the rising dissident tech world, and the religious right.
Obviously, our success has made us enemies, and we'll have to adjust our screening process. As a vocal (at times belligerent) atheist, James is not eligible to be published in American Reformer. Yes, James, you "got us" there, but we'll tighten that up.
I was fan of James' early work. It is sad to see him fall to these levels, boxed out of any meaningful political movement, and resorting to dumb tactics that will yield clicks in the short term, but destroy his credibility in the long term.
Those of us who care about the future of this country will keep about our work, fearlessly exploring serious ideas. We don't have time to navel gaze over James' petty resentments. Hey, if he keeps obsessively following us and regurgitating arguments, maybe he'll learn a thing or two - you never know.