It was, and remains, profoundly disturbing, the degree of behind-the-scenes effort required, befitting that of a well-executed PR stunt, to cancel Jon Pretty: The perfectly synchronized release of an open letter with its own website, a companion GitHub repository for signature collection, the phased release of follow-up blog posts, all cross-linked and simul-tweeted by the organizers and their associatesβan impregnable phalanx of fingers, all pointing toward one man.
What the allegations lacked in, well, allegations (there were, perplexingly, no claims much more concrete than the "victimization" of his victims) was more than compensated for by the verisimilar guilt stirred into existence with the suddenness and synchrony of the firing squad. A sufficiently interlinked skein of implications and vagaries can manifest its own sort of tautological proof, an unfortunate consequence of whichever primordial PageRank algorithm is preloaded onto our hindbrains.
All this, executed in such a manner as to preclude the mounting of any kind of defense, to precast skepticism, caution, or prudence as co-conspiracy, and to invoke a powerful social pressure (who signed? who didn't sign? when are you going to sign?) to lend your name to the pile.Β
All this was undertaken with the sole intent of unconditionally annihilating their target. They sought to ensure, by means of simulated unanimity, through a sophisticated social media campaign, a death blow. And quite possibly, a literal one, for all they knew.
I encourage everyone to read Jonβs account. It is titled "The Untold Impact of Cancellation," and it is simply that. It is also heartbreaking. If you signed the letter, please remove your name. If you are in any way involved with Scala's leadership, ensure his ability to participate in the community via public forums, conferences, or otherwise is swiftly reinstated.
I was cancelled in 2021 for something I didn't do. The impact this had on my life was devastating, but I've never had the courage to talk about it before.
This is my story of the misery that cancellation brought to my career, my social life and my health.
βββ