LEFT-WING ANTISEMITISM: THE THREAT DOWN THE STREET
When people downplay, deny, or justify left-wing antisemitism, what they fail to understand is that such antisemitism is a proximate threat to Jews. Jews predominantly live in the most liberal cities, in liberal states, attend liberal schools, have liberal and multicultural social circles. Jews count on those institutions as the basis for their social integration in the US.
Sure, right-wing antisemitism is a dangerous phenomenon, but it is socially, geographically, culturally, and institutionally more remote, relative to the location of the bulk of American Jewry. I won't be davening in northern Idaho any time soon; my kid's Hebrew school isn't in rural Kansas; I'm not trying to attend Liberty University. And that isn't even to claim those places are unsafe! But, presumably, I'd be more likely to encounter right-wing extremism and antisemitism in those places than elsewhere.
But if you tell me that my kids day school in suburban California is being picketed by people who justify and celebrate the murder of Jews on October 7, or my synagoge in Montreal got firebombed, or my Hasidic neighbor got jumped in Brooklyn, those are things that directly threaten many Jews - and those all keep happening.
Meanwhile, our ostensible allies are either downplaying it, quiet on it, or paying cynical lip-service to the fight against antisemitism without engaging in meaningful action. Liberal DAs are letting antisemitic rioters walk; school administrators are either throwing their arms up in the air or actively playing interference for institutionalized antisemitism, suppressing Jewish participation in higher ed; and, I hate to say it, but some members of communities we passionately supported in their moments of need are leaving us hanging - or worse.
We allied with LGBTQ folk so they could marry who they love; our communities sponsored refugees to escape oppression, a privilege and extension of friendship our own refugee ancestors never received; we've marched, and picketed, and went on strike, and organized in every major moment in American history - we have been at the front of the demand for cross-communal solidarity from. the. beginning.
And now, in our moment of need, we find that only our fellow Jews and what feels like a small handful of righteous allies will stand with us. Most folks keep their heads down, not wanting to lose friends or have a target on their back, fearful of having their lot indelibly thrown in with "those people." And some of our erstwhile "friends" - a small, but loud and aggressive minority - spit at us in the street, deny our peoplehood, mock our faith, claim our languages are made up or ugly or obsolete, castigate us as schemers and deceivers - in short, reproduce all the worst elements of historical, genocidal antisemitism.
We thought we left that all behind in the old world, across the ocean in the diasporic cage that is Afro-Eurasia. The pogroms, the forced segregation, the exclusion from society, the expulsions, the robberies, the rapes, the criminalization of our customs and languages, the special taxes, and the everyday indignities that were imposed, that was supposed to be over. No more Pale, no more jizya, no more libel, no more murder factories and death marches and mass graves.
But now we hear the echoes of our oh-so-recent history here, on the other side of the world, we see creeping shadows of evil increasingly tolerated in polite society, and we recoil as ancient, murderous rumors spring up anew and go largely unchallenged.
(Continued, 1/2)