Algernon Biddle Professor of Law & Professor of Philosophy; Faculty Director, Center for Ethics and the Rule of Law, University of Pennsylvania

Philadelphia, PA
I’m a law professor who has studied presidential power for years and I filed an amicus brief in this case. Good enough for you?
What are her credentials to be speaking on this issue?
104
195
3,070
265,144
It will take many years for us to tell the full story of the Trump Administration. When all is said and done, the role of Bill Barr will not be a pretty one. propublica.org/article/insid…
44
260
1,169
Barr’s Friday night massacre of Geoff Berman at the S.D.N.Y. must not stand. Barr is the head of DOJ, true, but if his purpose in this firing is to obstruct an official investigation, he is risking charges for obstruction of justice. apple.news/AgK07rO5yTDGtoVzJ…
54
325
968
This is a total outrage. Jared Kushner commissioned and then abandoned a rational plan for dealing with #COVID19 because it would only affect blue states! Or so they thought. Jared Kushner should resign.
BREAKING: My latest @VanityFair story, a detailed investigation into how the White House secretly drafted, then abandoned, a plan to nationalize America's broken #COVID19 diagnostic testing system. vanityfair.com/news/2020/07/… /1
82
402
983
Trump will likely be indicted after leaving office for financial crimes in New York. But he should also be investigated by the new Department of Justice for obstruction. nytimes.com/2020/11/13/nyreg…
67
187
925
Roger Stone's commutation is a profoundly concerning act of obstruction. But in the wake of #SCOTUS's clear indication in Vance that @realDonaldTrump is not above the law and can now be criminally investigated, #POTUS may be getting desperate. washingtonpost.com/opinions/…
42
300
841
1/2 Wednesday’s protests were in part organized by the Republican Attorneys General Association (RAGA). Senator Hawley was himself a member of RAGA apparently.
This was no spontaneous outburst. It was part of a well-funded criminal conspiracy to commit sedition and violently overthrow the United States government. Everyone involved must be held accountable. That includes Donald John Trump. dailykos.com/story/2021/1/8/…
14
288
837
This conduct should disqualify @realDonaldTrump from finishing his term. @SpeakerPelosi, now that your position is secure, let's make sure Donald Trump cannot run again in 2024!
This is criminal conduct under state and federal law. @realdonaldtrump should be impeached again NOW and tried and convicted after he leaves office so he can never hold public office again. washingtonpost.com/politics/…
17
197
674
This looks right to me, but even without the 28 U.S.C. 546(d) factor, Barr simply cannot fire Berman if the purpose is to put a stop to an ongoing investigation.
Berman is the Acting U.S. Attorney by dint of a *judicial* appointment. There’s a pretty good argument that, per the plain language of 28 U.S.C. § 546(d), he gets to keep serving in that post until the *vacancy* is filled (through Senate confirmation of a permanent successor).
11
209
623
It's worse than that. It looks as though Graham is proposing using the confirmation powers of the Senate to obstruct justice!
Lindsey Graham is threatening the Senate won’t confirm any AG who might prosecute Trump. So to be clear, he’s personally setting preconditions for what laws the nation’s chief law enforcement officer can enforce?
42
148
622
This is highly disturbing and shows @LindseyGrahamSC in the corrupt light that has been shining brighter on him every day for the last four years.
Lindsey Graham Says Senate Will NOT Confirm Any Biden AG Nominee Who Will Investigate/Prosecute Trump. There’s a legal term for this: ACCESSORY AFTER THE FACT. 18 US Code Sec. 3. Details here . . . Because #JusticeMatters piped.video/2EnN3MlFrdI via @YouTube
27
149
610
Our democracy barely survived its corrupt leadership and Postmaster General Louis DeJoy was up there with the worst of them. Moreover USPS is still not functioning well. @BillPascrell is right.
Today I am calling on President Biden to fire the entire Postal Board of Governors for their silence and complicity in trump and dejoy’s attempts to subvert the election and destroy the Post Office.
20
139
539
@LindseyGrahamSC has abused his office as Chairman of the Senate Judiciary Committee by pressuring the Georgia of Secretary of State to invalidate ballots. See my complaint with @RWPUSA and @waltshaub, and the story on CNN. nam02.safelinks.protection.o…
39
177
545
Seriously, how dumb does Ratcliffe think we are?!
Statement by DNI Ratcliffe: "I have confirmed that neither the President nor the Vice President were ever briefed on any intelligence alleged by the New York Times in its reporting yesterday." (1/2)
50
98
508
This is appalling. Whatever the GOP thinks of her decision, Liz Cheney broke no rules or laws and voted her conscience. The brown shirts are out in force in the U.S. Congress. nitter.app/i/events/1349436166446…
61
106
531
What more proof did we really need that the White House is directly colluding with Russian aggression against U.S. interests? @realDonaldTrump has told us so repeatedly. When will we finally believe him?
14
171
481
It will be a stain on Merrick Garland’s reputation, and permanently weaken the DOJ, if the Department does not take a very strong, clean stance on everyone who helped foment the 1/6 insurrection. Defending Mo Brooks would be even worse.
It is difficult to imagine an act that falls farther outside the scope of a congressman’s official duties than helping to provoke a crowd to lay siege on the center of our federal government, write @NormEisen, @daniellebrian and @DonaldAyer6nyti.ms/3zqC2TU
9
130
478
Thank you, @MittRomney, for being a voice of courage and integrity, all the more courageous because you are consistently alone among your GOP colleagues in the Senate.
Unprecedented, historic corruption: an American president commutes the sentence of a person convicted by a jury of lying to shield that very president.
21
81
477
January 6 will be remembered as the day democracy died. Today was the funeral. nytimes.com/live/2021/02/13/…
44
106
495
2/2. The list of corporate donors to RAGA includes Koch Industries, Comcast Corporation, Walmart, Home Depot, Amazon, TikTok, Chevron, The National Rifle Association, Monsanto Facebook, Fox Corporation, Uber, Coca Cola, Exxon, and Google.
1/2 Wednesday’s protests were in part organized by the Republican Attorneys General Association (RAGA). Senator Hawley was himself a member of RAGA apparently.
34
317
454
The question is what Berman is investigating that Bill Barr wants to impede. Epstein? The Trump Organization? The attorney general should show up and explain himself first thing Wednesday morning. See my op-Ed with @RWPUSA in Newsweek. newsweek.com/trumps-no-show-…
America is right to expect the worst of Bill Barr, who has repeatedly interfered in criminal investigations on Trump’s behalf. We have a hearing on this topic on Wednesday. We welcome Mr. Berman’s testimony and will invite him to testify.
14
140
439
This absolutely should have been disclosed by @AmyConeyBarrett and should raise serious concerns about her veracity.
Signing on to an ad that calls Roe v. Wade "barbaric" is the sort of thing a judicial nominee is usually supposed to disclose to the Senate while being considered.
22
227
447
This is a warning worth heeding, especially in Pennsylvania!
It’s too late to use the mails. Given Supreme Court rulings I urge everyone to now vote in person; early vote or use drop boxes. Protect your health but don’t let the Court and the deliberately crippled Postal Service deprive you of your most precious civil right. Plan your vote.
7
136
432
In my interview on #aljazeera this morning, I said imposing Rule 11 sanctions on the Trump lawyers who brought frivolous lawsuits would have helped to prevent this massive waste of taxpayer $ and distraction from the critical issues our country faces. mediaview.aljazeera.com/vide…
It’s time for bar associations to step up to the plate and discipline attorneys who abuse the system by flooding courts with claims lacking any basis in fact or in law: bostonglobe.com/2020/12/10/o…
12
67
434
Is there a lawyer in house? Donald Trump apparently has a problem. He has been deserted by his legal team a week before his impeachment trial begins. apnews.com/article/donald-tr…
98
78
412
This calls for witnesses. The Senate should call them.
Wow. Trump lawyers have no explanation of what Trump knew on day of Capitol riot or what he did to stop it beyond a single tweet. Stunning.
9
70
414
This article from June in The Atlantic gives a detailed and cogent narrative suggesting that the foreign interference in 2016 may have been only the appetizer. The main dish is about to come. theatlantic.com/magazine/arc…
19
252
388
I just heard a commentator say that Trump's defense was a "My Cousin Vinny" moment. Please don't insult a fabulous movie showing what ultimately was a great courtroom performance. These lawyers should watch it and take some lessons.
13
31
409
When the Secretary of War, Belknap, was tried in 1876 following his impeachment and resignation, he was no longer holding office in the federal government. That is our only precedent, and it permits this case. There is no precedent on the other side.
5
95
393
The Trump Campaign today filed this lawsuit in a Federal District Court in PA. They want an injunction to stop the Secretary of State from certifying the results of the election. They can huff and puff but they won't blow the house down. cdn.donaldjtrump.com/public-…
15
76
372
Had @Twitter done this in 2017, January 6, 2021 might never have happened.
BREAKING: Twitter announces that Trump’s ban is permanent— even if he runs for president in 2024.
13
58
347
This is very worthy of investigation. Lot all of @realDonaldTrump’s policy decisions, a profit motive is usually not far to seek.
9
92
354
Shocking, but not surprising. Why was 45 not led away on January 20th in handcuffs?!
If you want to know who started the insurrection, ask the question we asked after 9-11: Who paid for it? Trump. Trump’s political operation paid more than $4.3 million to Jan. 6 organizers but questions remain about the full extent of its involvement opensecrets.org/news/2021/08…
9
96
362
Rep. Mo Brooks is demanding that DOJ represent him under the Westfall Act in the suit brought by Rep. Swalwell for his role in fomenting the Capitol riot. His reason? He claims he was acting "in the scope of his employment" when he supported the BIG LIE. To DOJ: JUST SAY NO.
33
69
340
Terrific piece by @jckendall about @BandyXLee1 who was terminated by Yale University for trying the warn the country about the danger posed by @POTUS45. Yale should reinstate her and reaffirm the principle of open expression on university campuses. nam02.safelinks.protection.o…
13
97
351
In order to invoke the 25th Amendment, all that needs to happen is for @VP to transmit a letter, along with a majority of Trump's cabinet, to @SpeakerPelosi and @ChuckGrassley saying that @realDonaldTrump is unfit for office. Pence would immediately become the Acting President.
19
94
328
Merrick Garland is a fabulous choice for attorney general! And this time ⁦@senatemajldr⁩ cannot scuttle his confirmation. politico.com/news/2021/01/06…
7
33
339
Pennsylvania AG blasts Texas election suit as 'seditious abuse' of judicial process thehill.com/homenews/campaig…
6
52
320
We will be investigating the perfidies of Trump's family and associates for many years. Biden should appoint a special counsel.
Remember that Deutsche Bank appears to have failed to monitor and report suspicious financial activity found in accounts controlled by President Trump and Jared Kushner, raising serious questions about the bank’s compliance with anti-money laundering rules citizensforethics.org/news/p…
11
56
329
No veteran can support this Commander-in-Chief without asking themselves how much they truly stand with those currently in uniform.
Once again, it’s #AmericaOrTrump.
11
109
316
This is ridiculous. Doesn’t she know we only use our space lasers to light Chanukah candles?!
"Most Republicans are probably quite skeptical that the California wildfires were intentionally set by a Jewish space laser." We sure hope so, but we wonder sometimes. nymag.com/intelligencer/arti…
19
53
332
The Senate must subpoena Donald Trump and enforce it in federal court if he does not comply. Now that he is no longer president, his only grounds for refusing to testify would be that he intends to take the 5th. And that, in itself, would be telling.
BREAKING: House Impeachment Managers Request Former President Trump Testify Under Oath Next Week medium.com/housejudiciary/ho…
12
76
320
Former Chief of Staff to Colin Powell, Larry Wilkerson, says he would have Michael Flynn court-martialed for "incitement to insurrection." See my piece with @RWPUSA in @just_security on this same topic. piped.video/6xARYtEal-g via @YouTube
8
104
313
BIBAS, Circuit Judge: “Free, fair elections are the lifeblood of our democracy. Charges of unfairness are seri- ous. But calling an election unfair does not make it so. Charges require specific allegations and then proof. We have neither here.” ca3.uscourts.gov/opinarch/20…
I am proud of my former colleague, now Judge Stephanos Bibas, for this wise and forceful decision. apple.news/Ai5IXVBsCQb2Ju5t1…
4
57
327
Manafort can now testify at the trial of @realDonaldTrump for obstruction of justice.
11
61
297
Louis DeJoy needs to go. He subverted USPS to aid Trumps reelection campaign and sought to exploit it to line his pockets. @JoeBiden should fire the postal board and replacing it with persons of integrity who care about ensuring USPS serves the needs of all Americans equally.
Just because Trump is out doesn’t mean that all his cronies are. Like Trump-appointed Postmaster General Louis DeJoy who slowed mail and removed mailboxes right before the election with the greatest number of Americans voting by mail to date. npr.org/2021/01/29/961667755…
11
82
291
It is critical that this investigation proceed to completion. This may be the only accountability Trump encounters.
Memo to Cy Vance, Manhattan DA: Beef up your security team. Wear body armor. Hire a really good food-taster. Maybe two. nytimes.com/2021/02/25/nyreg…
4
63
297
Extraordinary testimony by former GOP official Matthew Pottinger. A committed conservative, he knew the danger for the country of Trump’s attack on the peaceful transition of power — both with our enemies and with our allies. This is not a partisan matter. #January6thHearing
13
58
288
Exile-in-chief'? Trump a 'flight risk' if criminal charges are filed, experts say washingtontimes.com/news/202… via @washtimes
46
73
299
So tell me, did Chuck Schumer just throw House managers under the bus?
49
53
282
Agreed. Next steps await. Appoint a special prosecutor.
Alright. Let’s get Merrick Garland confirmed so we can begin the criminal investigations into the insurrection leaders, and in between Covid relief budget reconciliation votes, let’s get the house and senate committees to open investigations and call witnesses in those forums.
10
57
277
Amazing that @LindseyGrahamSC persists with efforts to reverse the election after the criticism he received for his attempt to intervene in Georgia! See the ethics complaint I filed with @RWPUSA and @waltshaub demanding that the Senate Ethics Committee. assets.documentcloud.org/doc…
Lindsey Graham has received intense blowback for suggesting that Georgia officials throw out legally cast ballots in the state and questioning Arizona’s mail-in voting process. We’re investigating. citizensforethics.org/report…
18
55
263
Trump just admitted his motivation for placing a loyalist like Amy Coney Barrett on the Court, and getting the Senate Republicans to rush through the confirmation process.
Trump just said it at Reading PA rally: “If we win on Tuesday or — thank you very much, Supreme Court — shortly thereafter…"
19
98
278
More on the Republican attorney generals. The violence and break in of the Capitol Building on 1/6 looks more and more like a well-executed plan with high level involvement of elected and appointed officials, and less and less like a spontaneous occurrence.
15
111
272
Favorite quote: “Perhaps the most dangerous lie . . . was that the election was stolen. Of course it wasn’t, but a huge number of Republican leaders encouraged the belief that it was. Every time that lie was repeated, the riots of Jan. 6 became more likely.
”We’ll never move forward by ignoring what happened or refusing to hold accountable those responsible. That will embolden the few who led us here and dishearten the many who know America is better than this.” washingtonpost.com/opinions/…
5
69
263
The NY Ct. of Appeals ruled that @PaulManafort can't be prosecuted under NY law for crimes closely related to the federal offenses for which he was tried and pardoned. But presidents have no power over state crimes, and thus the federal pardon should free Vance up to prosecute.
7
61
266
Way to go DOJ! This is a far cry from representing Trump against E. Jean Carroll. We seem to be going in the right direction.
BREAKING: Merrick Garland’s DoJ OLC has released a memo ordering the Treasury to hand trump’s taxes over to the House Ways and Means Committee.
4
39
245
Trump is feeling the heat of increased public knowledge about his taxes, his business empire and the self-inflicted wound of his dishonest financial practices. When the going gets tough, the tough start suing. msn.com/en-us/news/politics/…
19
57
258
See my op-ed with @RWPUSA on Lindsey Graham's unethical conduct in Georgia. nbcnews.com/think/opinion/se…
8
65
249
Extraordinary picture of national guardsmen asleep in the Capitol building to protect it from insurgents. How did it come to this?!
42
45
270
Merrick Garland got it right! Time to rethink the decision to support Trump against E. Jean Carroll.
4
43
239
Their argument is that Flynn was lying when he said he spoke to the Russians, so that he was telling the truth when he said he didn't speak to the Russians! Was he lying when he admitted he lied to investigators?! Do two lies make a truth?
16
59
231
And many other charges. #DOJ has no choice but to act. The #January6thCommittee has forced its hand.
Did Trump commit a crime? "This is the smoking gun," Sol Wisenberg, a former deputy to Ken Starr, tells me about today's hearing. "There isn’t any question this establishes a prima facie case for his criminal culpability on seditious conspiracy charges."
8
56
219
This op-Ed gets it exactly right. Accountability is critical. But it would help if Congress revived the special counsel law first. We need to put sensitive political investigations as much beyond the reach of partisan politics as possible. latimes.com/opinion/story/20…
4
62
233
Free legal advice for DT: it would be better not to draw attention to your complicity in a crime by calling a press conference at your home on the first anniversary of its commission.
Trump officially announces January 6th anniversary press conference at Mar-a-Lago rawstory.com/trump-capitol-r…
32
50
231
The president’s signature on a bill signals his acceptance of its contents as constitutional. If he truly believes it is not constitutional, his oath of office requires that he not sign it. If he does, he must abide by its contents. #RuleOfLaw
“I believe that elements of this law are unconstitutional or infringe on my executive powers. Therefore, I am signing this into law, but I reserve the right to ignore certain parts of it or to interpret it as I see fit.” ⁦@realDonaldTrumpnbcnews.com/politics/congres…
11
69
214
If @LindseyGrahamSC did not try to disenfranchise voters in GA by calling @GabrielSterling’s boss—see complaint I filed against Graham with @waltshaub and @RWPUSA—he must decry this intimidation of a Georgia election official just trying to do his job. amp.cnn.com/cnn/2020/11/18/p…
So this is fun...multiple attempted hacks of my emails, police protection around my home, the threats. But all is well...following the the law, following the process...doing our jobs.
6
66
224
Important development in the fight to hold this and all future accountable.
Unsurprising but very welcome development: DC circuit grants rehearing en banc in both the McGahn case and the subpoena of Mueller material case. Plus Trump’s two appointees are recused. Hearing on April 28. Look for the McGahn case to be reversed and the subpoena case affirmed.
7
46
215
Faculty shouldn't comment on the behavior of former students, right. But when their students become U.S. Senators, they are open to public scrutiny. When they engage with insurrectionists who violently attack the Capitol, it is not just permissble, but obligatory, to speak up.
5
43
217
People are stabbed and beaten up by Proud Boys in DC, the Michigan statehouse closes out of fear of violence, and @KLoeffler poses with a white supremacist during a reelection campaign. The US is having a dangerous romance with racism and authoritarianism. washingtonpost.com/nation/20…
27
75
213
Can’t imagine why Jared didn’t take care of this. I thought he already made peace in the Middle East!
Psaki says U.S. officials heavily involved in seeking ‘de-escalation’ between Israel military and Gaza militants Via @WPJohnWagner washingtonpost.com/politics/…
7
42
227
As I told Newsweek today, Rudy Giuliani could face charges for criminal sedition or other crimes based on his encouragement to an angry mob to engage in “trial by combat” and assistance to Donald Trump in the run up to January 6th. newsweek.com/legal-experts-s…
15
67
224
Donald Trump remains at large and dangerous. His followers need straight talk about the crimes he has likely committed and the urgency of prosecuting him even for the most extreme of them. Read my take with ⁦@RWPUSA⁩ in #washingtonpost here. washingtonpost.com/outlook/2…
20
79
213
“As Commander in Chief, President Trump ... has an obligation under both domestic and international law to at least not impede processes to hold war criminals responsible, and his pardon powers do not override that responsibility,” says Gabor Rona. justsecurity.org/64288/can-a…
11
52
219
“I am going to do everything in my power to put this dark chapter behind us.” Senator Durbin concluding the Senate is Judiciary Committee hearings on closing Guantanamo. I cannot think of a better chair for this committee.
6
39
217
Congratulations to @KamalaHarris and @DouglasEmhoff for finding happiness in love and making room for it in their lives. Part of a life worth living.
The morning after our first date, @DouglasEmhoff emailed me a list of his available dates for the next couple of months: 'I want to see if we can make this work.' And we did. Dougie, happy birthday. I could not imagine anyone else I’d rather be with on this journey called life.
2
26
208
Invoking Martial Law to Reverse the 2020 Election Could be Criminal Sedition justsecurity.org/73986/invok… via @just_security
6
46
195
By the same logic, Trump should not be able to pardon Michael Flynn either, since the purpose would be the self-serving one of obstructing an inquiry into his own wrongdoing.
Don’t even think about it Donny.... No, Trump can’t pardon himself. The Constitution tells us so. - The Washington Post washingtonpost.com/opinions/…
5
41
197
This report provides a roadmap to the problematic tenure of William Barr at the Department of Justice. Further investigation by Congress will be necessary to plumb the depths of his perfidy.
So what did William Barr accomplish as Attorney General? Our 200 plus page report from @PennLaw_CERL and @CREWcrew is here. Download, read and circulate this report on the worst Attorney General in American history. law.upenn.edu/institutes/cer…
7
60
197
This is hardly a surprise. Yet there has been no accountability for what can only be called a disinformation campaign, pure and simple. All of this information should be weighed and sifted by a special prosecutor. But ignoring history dooms us to repetition, as the saying goes.
Breaking News: The Trump campaign knew days after the 2020 election that wild claims of voting machine tampering — pushed by Sidney Powell and others allied with Donald Trump — were not true, court filings show. Still, they promoted the false theories. nyti.ms/2VXXsJJ
4
56
197
It is deeply concerning that anyone who was involved with, or tried to justify, the Bush era torture program continues to be involved with public policy. John Yoo should not be consulting with @realDonaldTrump, and @GinaHaspell1 should not be Director of the CIA.
If the federal government had listened to @COFinkelstein back in 2010 about prosecuting torture lawyers, John Yoo now might not be advising @realDonaldTrump on his "unitary executive" theory for authoritarian rule. Read all about it here: scholarship.law.upenn.edu/cg…
6
55
183
We must not be complacent about the ability of #Ukraine to hold out without outside military intervention. Economic sanctions will not do it. Heavier Russian tanks are already reportedly on their way, and Putin’s anger is a harbinger of what is surely to come.
5
40
200
Congress should hold hearings into the firing of all these IG’s. On second thought, what could they uncover if they did? POTUS is not hiding why he’s doing it ...
Yet another inspector general is fired by the most corrupt president in American history. We'd better fire him in November or it's four more years of cover ups, retaliation, and incompetence. cnn.com/2020/05/15/politics/…
12
51
191
Lest his rejection of the Trump fraud myth about the 2020 election should cause us to rethink our criticisms of Bill Barr, here is a reminder of who he really is -- the most heartless and corrupt attorney general the US has ever had.
BREAKING: The Trump administration was in such a rush to execute people that it sought to enter into a no-bid contract with the seller of the drug used in the lethal injection, according to new documents obtained by CREW. citizensforethics.org/report…
11
46
188