What a surprise... Zarah is being attacked for all the wrong reasons by Owen Jones and all the other left-liberals. How dare she criticize the Greens!! How dare she insist on opposing NATO and Zionism!!
Genuine respect for Zarah:
But the Greens support proscribing the IDF as a terrorist organisation and support Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions.
The Greens are obviously embracing class politics under Zack Polanski - from a wealth tax to abolishing landlords.
Polanski is also pushing for alternatives to NATO.
The danger is a lot of people on the left will see this as contrived - as looking for differences for the sake of it to justify Your Party's existence.
Also: Your Party doesn't have any policies yet, and many of the independent MPs aligned to it are to the right of the Greens on some issues.
Zarah has made her differences with them clear on that - but it leads you to conclude that Zarah is articulating her own personal views, which is entirely reasonable, rather than the platform of a party that doesn't exist yet.
Personally, I'd have preferred a class-based leftist party. The danger is Your Party has been so messy that a lot of its potential support has gone to the Greens.
Another danger for Your Party here is that Zack Polanski's media appearances are very effectively talking to the public at large, and talk about (minor) differences on NATO will contrast with that.
It's also difficult to make this critique of the Greens land well when their membership and polling support is surging on a platform of left-wing economics and opposition to Israel's genocide.
If Your Party was doing well, it would land better, but its current weakness undermines that.
I totally understand that Zarah was asked a question here, rather than bringing it up herself.
But she's outlined these differences before, and I don't think it's going to convince a significant number of people to choose Your Party over the Greens?
It will talk to a very small number of very committed left-wing activists, but they're mostly in the bag anyway.
A better bet, surely, would be to
a) focus on neutralising the concerns people have about Your Party - which includes the divisions and a lack of ideological coherence
b) make compelling interventions that pitch left-wing arguments at a mass audience
Whatever happens, I hope some sort of pact can be struck between the Greens and whatever Your Party becomes. And she talks here about working with the Greens, which is important.
It's notable that Your Party is attracting huge numbers to their meetings. That energy is crucial to what comes next.
And obviously Jeremy Corbyn and Zarah Sultana are massively important figures on the left. The left needs them both! And right now there's a huge opportunity to displace Labour with a united left.
I'm just not sure this is the best strategy, personally, and I think it risks marginalising the Your Party initiative when it's already been weakened by public divisions and the Green surge.
The Your Party founding conference is in a month - let's hope it's in a better place, then!