This is an attempt of a more coherent thread of why, imo, yesterday's prediction of a flat band at the Fermi level in #LK99 does not "bring us back" or does resolve the controversy. In short, the prediction assumes the proposed crystal structure is correct, but it might not be.
Finally it is official! Delighted to report that Leslie has been promoted to Associate Professor with tenure effective July first. Obviously this group deserves all the credit. Best lab ever!!! 🎉🥳😊
Okay I think I need to comment here. It does not surprise me that there is a flatband with the assumed structure. More below. Problem is, is the structure correct? I have doubts. Would like to see phonon calculations to if it’s stable. Can you do this next?
First phonons out (I would like to see more to me sure). Based on these phonons the crystal structure seems not stable to me, especially in context of the synthesis conditions. I would be extremely cautious about any predictions based on this crystal structure.
A belated happy new year from the Schoop lab! We start the year with the great news that we have been granted an @NSF CAREER grant. Stay tuned for more work on topological square- net materials!
In a Material where I replace Pb2+ (s0) with Cu2+ (d9) it is very expected that a flat band will appear because what should the lonely d9 electrons do if they are not allowed to magnetize? They will make a flat band. This is why chemically it seems weird this doping is possible
Hard disagree here. The problem is not a lack in precision of the analysis but a lack in proof that any predicted new material has actually been made. AI could very well made up materials that don’t exist. So far based on the analysis here, proof that these can be made is lacking
We are also delighted to introduce Prof. Leslie Schoop @SchoopLab@PrincetonChem as the journal's first Topic Editor. Welcome Leslie! Here is the link to her group's website: go.acs.org/3G
We are excited to share our awesome work on synthesizing a superconducting ink made of 1T-WS2 monolayers, led by @XiaoyuSong2 ! Here we show you can use chemical exfoliation to mass-produce high-quality 2D quantum materials. Also, the ink is stable in air! science.org/doi/10.1126/scia…
It was very nice to collaborate with @Robert_Palgrave and students to analyze the autonomous lab paper.Our findings are summarized in the thread here. Most crucial finding imo is that compositional disorder in materials cannot be neglected,as is can lead to incorrect conclusions.
We have now completed our analysis of new materials reported in the Google Deepmind / Berkeley autonomous lab paper. My own initial analysis is in the quote tweet.
Happy to have worked with @SchoopLab to jointly put together a comprehensive analysis, now available on @ChemRxiv.
This thread is my personal view after having looked at the detail of each of the materials reported 🧵
chemrxiv.org/engage/chemrxiv…
In the mean time DFT people could do a phonon calculation, which could give us more insight into whether the structure is correct. Imo that would be the easiest next step to check.
Flat bands usually indicate that our structure is not stable. They could also indicate superconductivity, but only if you are 100% certain that the structure you inputted into the DFT calculation is correct. Very often, seeing flat bands says your structure is wrong.
This is really nice work from Beijing here about Cu2S, which has a structural phase transition at 385K and can explain the observed resistivity in #LK99 . It also nice compliments our work. arxiv.org/pdf/2308.04353.pdf
This exciting paper shows AI design of materials, robotic synthesis. 10s of new compounds in 17 days.
But did they?
This paper has very serious problems in materials characterisation. In my view it should never have got near publication. Hold on tight let's take a look 😱
We are excited to announce the 2020 #PackardFellows in Science and Engineering! Over the next 5 years, these 20 @PackardFdn Fellows will engage in groundbreaking scientific research and reach new frontiers of discovery. Meet the Fellows: bit.ly/fellows20.
Today, Xiaoyu @XiaoyuSong2 successfully defended her thesis with an amazing talk about her work on 2D materials. She is the first student from our lab to pass this milestone! Next she will move across the country to work with @DKBediako. We are very proud of you!
Congrats to Leslie Schoop @SchoopLab and Bob Cava, both awarded 5-year, $1.7M @MooreFound EPiQS grants. Ready to take on Heisenberg who said, “Not only is the Universe stranger than we think, it is stranger than we can think.”
bit.ly/SchoopCavaEPiQS
1. Samples following the described synthesis are multi-phase
2. Single crystals of an apatite phase can be isolated and are transparent. Our SXRD solution agrees with published powder pattern
3. Cu doping on Pb site seems not feasible based on formation energy calculations
Happy to share Milena's @SuperChemGirl work on chemical rules for kagome materials. We found a tolerance factor that allows to easily predict when they have the typical "kagome bands." We hope it helps many of you finding cool new kagome materials.@J_A_C_Sshorturl.at/bhCLX
The whole Frick community turned out to support Leslie Schoop for her Friday lecture, “The Chemistry of Quantum Materials.” As Dept Chair Greg Scholes said, “What she’s done since she’s been @PrincetonChem is nothing short of extraordinary.” #WomenInSTEM
ALT Color image of Leslie Schoop smiling after completing her lecture Friday afternoon. Photo by C. Todd Reichart
Huge quantum oscillations discovered in a 2D topological insulator! Could this be a sign of neutral fermions? Glad to be part of this work with the Wu lab @PrincetonPhys. Awesome for us: Crystal purity strongly enhances the signature :) nature.com/articles/s41586-0…@nature@pccm_mrsec
Issue with DFT is that crap in crap out so this result entirely relies on the structure being correct. If yes great, if not then it means nothing. So while chemists figure out the structure it might be helpful if DFT people could calculate the phonons and tell us if it’s stable
After living in 2D square-net works for a long time we have now extended our considerations to 3D. Check out our work on topology in superconducting LaIn3. Nice collaboration with Sam Teicher form UCSB! @ChemMaterpubs.acs.org/doi/abs/10.1021…
Earlier this week the Schoop lab’s graduates #1 and #2 were officially hooded! Congratulations to Xiaoyu and Robert, we are so proud! Also, the only decent picture we could find includes the youngest lab member, who is also very proud 😂
Check out Mulan's new paper describing how chemical exfoliation can be used to make 1D nanostructures of ionically bound materials. And they can maintain their magnetism during the process! Published in @nanoscale_rscpubs.rsc.org/en/content/arti…
We are pleased to announce the 2021 cohort of the Sloan Research Fellows. These extraordinary early career researchers represent some of the most exciting young minds working today! We are so thrilled to be able to support your work! #sloanfellowtinyurl.com/phsojiu9
So what to next to figure this out? 1. solid-state chemists need to perform a really careful analysis on the material (if you have a floating sample feel free to ship it to us) to really nail down what the crystal structure is, so we have more confidence in the DFT input.
Here comes the first battery paper from the Schoop lab. Graduate student @StilesJoseph (joint with @CraigArnoldLab) found that pre-treating NaCrS2 with a mild acid dramatically improves its capacity as a Na-Anode. read the full story at: onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/…#battchat
Check out Fang's @FangYua16672278 new paper on atomic resolution imaging of monolayer and twisted bilayer WTe2, together with the Wu group and Princeton's IAC. It wasn't easy to fix samples on a grid, read more to find out what did the trick. @NanoLetterspubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acs…
And finally: even if we assume the Cu doped structure to be correct, theory predicts (for the given structure) a magnetic ground state due to localized flat bands.
Today Robert successfully defended his PhD, being the second graduate from our lab. He was joined with the Scholes lab and gave a great talk on the spectroscopy of materials! His work enabled new areas of research in both labs, he clearly leaves a legacy.Congratulations Dr. Kirby
Sometimes chemical exfoliation is the superior way for making 2D quantum materials! Grace's paper about the exfoliation of VOCl monolayers appeared today in @acsnano. After exfoliation and re-stacking randomly, the magnetic order is maintained.#womeninSTEMpubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/acs…
Check out our newest paper from @RatnadwipSingha and more about an air-stable 2D material with high mobility and probably also magnetism. This follows up on our work on GdTe3, where the air sensitivity is an issue. This is now solved with TaCo2Te2. bit.ly/3ksLctS
Did you know there is a better way to grow superconducting 2M-WS2 as what is currently in the literature? Check out Xiaoyu's @XiaoyuSong2 and Brianna's paper! (equal contribution) And let us know if you want some high-quality xtals :) @ChemMaterpubs.acs.org/doi/full/10.102…
Check out Brianna's work about making thin sheets out of a 3D solid using a clever chemical route. Published in JPhys Materials' focus issue on Women’s Perspective in Quantum Materials. #WomenInSTEMiopscience.iop.org/article/1…
The proposed structure in the original two papers is based on a not very well-performed x-ray analysis. @Robert_Palgrave described this better before me. It makes assumptions that are chemically questionable and the chemical reaction is not balanced.
Thus before I put any faith in the proposed structure I would like to see a better x-ray analysis. Together with chemical analysis and more. Now let's get to what this means for the prediction of a flat band.
@Robert_Palgrave summarized the chemistry better and I don’t want to repeat it, summary is there are lots of things unclear with the proposed crystal structure
Black Lives Matter. Racism in science persists to this day, and the diversity crisis in STEM is one symptom of graver and deadlier systemic problems in the US. We as scientists reject the false luxury of remaining silent and urge our peers to act for change in every way possible.
Let's assume for a sec the structure is correct. In this case Cu2+ was substituted for Pb2+. Those two elements are chemically very different so that would be surprising, but let's for now assume it happened.
After having studied rare earth tellurides and their Sb doped versions for a while, we now looked at rare earth diantimonides (NdSb2 here) and found that they also are low-dimensional high-mobility magnets. Find out more in @RatnadwipSingha's latest paper. onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/…
The lone Cu d electron now does not know what to do. Usually it would try to magnetize. Or find something from the environment to react with. If you model this case with density functional theory (DFT) as was done in the prediction, you will see a flat band.
I am honored to join the amazing chemistry department at NC State University, where I will establish a group focused on theoretical research of quantum materials!
.@SchoopLab publishes on a mechanism to design clean, nonsymmorphic Dirac semimetals, uncovering electronic behaviors that were theorized but not demonstrated. Well done Leslie, Shiming, Kehan, Tyger, @PrincetonPhys and collaborators : bit.ly/3hAymbW
ALT Color image of Department of Chemistry Assistant Professor Leslie Schoop at her office desk.
Experimental evidence for the existence of three-dimensional Dirac fermions in Au₂Pb confirms a theoretically predicted Dirac semimetal phase with a fourfold degenerate Dirac crossing protected by rotational lattice symmetry. go.aps.org/3Nls9QY#PRL
Check out Connor’s @ConnorPollak first paper in which we show that 1 D electronic properties can exist in a 3D crystal if the 1D motif is surrounded by an electrically inert scaffold. Nice collaboration with @Gvamvim@ionerrea and @FPielnhofer
So proud of one of my oldest friends and looking forward to continuing our collaborations! Also everyone please follow @MuechlerLab and new grad students or graduating students consider working for this awesome scientist!!
The Penn State Department of Chemistry is pleased to announce that Lukas Muechler will be joining the department faculty as an assistant professor of chemistry! Read more: buff.ly/3icytLn
Did you know that a charge density wave can template a magnetic structure? check out Tyger's @crystal_bubbe beautiful paper about the connection of a CDW and an elliptical cycloid magnetic structure in NdSbxTe2-x! journals.aps.org/prmaterials…
Yesterday’s socially distant outdoor lab party to celebrate Leslie winning the Packard fellowship and to say goodbye to Shiming who is leaving us soon.
In that case Cu2+, which has 9 d electrons, meaning 1 electron is unpaired, will sit on a site that previously did not have any unpaired electrons (Pb2+ has two electrons in its 6s orbital and no other).
Our perspective with @Robert_Palgrave , discussing the challenges of autonomous materials discovery is now published! Check out the final version at @PRX_Energy
Autonomous materials discovery could rapidly accelerate the development of energy technology. This #Perspective from @SchoopLab & @Robert_Palgrave highlights limitations in the autonomous identification of new materials and identifies current bottlenecks.
doi.org/10.1103/PRXEnergy.3.…
Of course an automatic lab can accelerate accidents but that’s just not as cool as if it finds targeted new predictions. Please prove that part unambiguously!
I get the argument that the automated lab is not supposed to do everything. But if you make the big claim that you predicted and then synthesized new materials you also need to fully prove that you really made them. I just see now way around that.
We are happy to share Robert's newest paper, where we investigate the ultrafast dynamics of GdSbxTe2-x, which are CDW-modulated topological semimetals. Rob was a joint student between us and the Scholes group at @PrincetonChem, he graduated last summer. pubs.acs.org/doi/full/10.102…
Nice story about how we contributed to the discovery of the axial Higgs mode by @Burch_Lab . A good tale about chemists can have an impact by suggesting the right materials. Solid-state chemistry is so beautiful :)
Check out our newest review about the prospects of chemical exfoliation for 2D quantum materials in @AppliedPhysRev: doi.org/10.1063/5.0038644
This was the lockdown project of Xiaoyu (@XiaoyuSong2), Fang, and Leslie and also happens to be an all-female author paper.#WomenInSTEM
No they did not. based on the x-ray analysis there can be side phases. Main phase is an old new material, extra elements can make side phases, which you can see as unfit peaks in the data. There are many very boring explanations for the results that don’t involve new structures
Please read below the really fun story of we found, together with the Wu group, a new way to make 2D materials, where metals form shockingly uniform films on top of TMDs, well below their melting temperature.
Leslie Schoop @SchoopLab and Sanfeng Wu @PrincetonPhys publish their latest in @NatureSynthesis: “Surface-confined two-dimensional mass transport and crystal growth on monolayer materials.” Congratulations Yanyu, Leslie, Sanfeng, and labs!
Story: bit.ly/3uBo848
ALT Full-color image of Leslie Schoop and Sanfeng Wu seated in Schoop's office.
ALT This two-figure graphic portrays the transport of the material across the seed bed.
Check out Fang's newest paper where we describe new synthesis routes to make magnetic, Mn-doped SnS2 nanosheets. Our method makes it possible to increase the solubility on Mn4+ in SnS2. @ChemMaterpubs.acs.org/doi/full/10.102…
Check out Leslie's and Jason's @JasonKhoury1 new review article in @TrendsChemistry ! We discuss why chemical bonds matter for topological materials :) Lot's of fun to think about 😊 sciencedirect.com/science/ar…
Check out our new paper that just appeared in @PhysRevB on the signature of an ultrafast photo-induced Lifshitz transition in the topological semimetal ZrSiTe! Read more here: journals.aps.org/prb/abstrac…
Very excited about this work with @Burch_Lab . Since our 2020 paper on high mobility in GdTe3 we always knew this material is full of wonders. Now it shows the fist example of an asymmetrical Higgs!
With postdoc @NitishMathur19 and a collaboration with @SongJin_Chem , the Schoop lab is going 1D! Check out these nanowires that should contain internal Fermi arcs at their twin boundary. @NanoLetters
The gender ratio in this picture is depressing. This does not send a good message to young women thinking of going into science. Any plans to address this @maxplanckpress ?
3 Days and 20 talks later!
Our PhDs and scientists from @Uni_Stuttgart, @uni_ulm, and @mpifkf spent the last 3 days on our online IQST PhD retreat. More than 50 participants overcame the physical distance and enjoyed exciting talks, discussions, and coffee breaks👩🎓☕️🎉
#quantum
Topological semimetals GdSbxTe2-x exhibit crazy magnetism... See details in our newest paper that just appeared in @PhysRevB . We also see a signature that could come from antiferromagnetic skyrmions. Read more here: journals.aps.org/prb/abstrac…
Check out our latest collaboration with Jennifer Cano @FlatironCCQ , where we dive into the physics of square-net-based #topological semimetals, finding that filling enforced semimetals can exist without nonsymmorphic symmetry. @PhysRevB@PrincetonChemjournals.aps.org/prb/abstrac…
We are excited to share that Leslie was selected to be a Beckman Young Investigator! Thanks so much to @BeckmanFdn for supporting our research! #BYI#BeckmanFoundation
Cool stuff can happen in extra clean crystals! Check out our latest work in @PhysRevB about transport anomalies in high-quality NdTe3 crystals. This work was done with visiting graduate student Kirstine. Congrats Kirstine! Read more at link.aps.org/doi/10.1103/Phy…#WomenInSTEM
Great new research out today from @SchoopLab in @ScienceAdvances announcing a simple chemical exfoliation method that produces a high-quality, superconducting nanosheet ink that is stable in air. Congrats Xiaoyu, Ratnadwip and Leslie. Story: bit.ly/3n7BuRP#Chemistry
ALT Illustrative graphic courtesy of Science Advances.
Check out Robert's new perspective article on square-net topological semimetals and spectroscopy in the Journal of Physical Chemistry Letters! pubs.acs.org/doi/full/10.102…
Are those newly predicted materials new structures or just doped versions of Sn2Pb2O7? It seems you predict some oxygen loss. I’m asking because finding new substituted materials is a lot less exciting than new structures.
Congratulations to our former postdoc Sebastian for winning the attract grant! Sebastian will lead a junior group @Fraunhofer_IWKS . We are proud of you! iwks.fraunhofer.de/de/presse…
To end I would like to say it’s cool that robots can make samples. How big of the deal this is, depends on if they actually made something that was predicted BEFORE. Accidental new materials discoveries happen periodically in our lab, I’m sure then also in A-lab.
Thanks to Tyger for representing our group at the department retreat! Very sad I had to miss her talk, I heard it was spectacular!!! It’s nice to be able to count on everyone in the group 😍
Check out Xiaoyu's laters paper on the chemistry behind the synthesis of cdW magnet CrSe2. @ChemMater This also marks Leslie's 100th publication 🎉🥳🎉 pubs.acs.org/doi/full/10.102…