At showcases, catcher's pop times are now akin to slam dunk contests: numerous attempts without consequence. One catcher, consistently accurate with times like 1.95, 1.98, 1.94, and 1.97, ranks 10th on a leaderboard. Meanwhile, another catcher, after four botched transfer attempts, records a 1.81 and secures 2nd place on some graphic viewed by thousands of people. This isn't a true 1.81; four potential stolen bases due to dropped transfers and a significant tag delay on the 5th throw.
Pop times should account for accuracy. Off-target throws could add up to 0.5 seconds for tag adjustments, and slightly misplaced throws might add 0.2-0.3 seconds. Multiple Errors like bobbles and drops should be noted with an asterisk on the pop time.
In fact, bring a hack attack machine out. Throw 90mph fastballs, two throws with left handed batters in box, two throws with right handed batter in box. Then switch to breaking balls: 2 throws with lefty in the box, 2 throws with a righty in the box.
You do that and it will be very apparent which players have a chance to catch and throw with accuracy and I promise you won’t need a stopwatch to differentiate between them.