Fannie/Freddie should be released from conservatorship because that’s the law, it’s really not any more complicated than that…and it’s not a “difficult” or “complex” process, it’s fairly straightforward
There were around 7,600 banks when Dodd-Frank was passed, now there are around 4,500, Dodd-Frank & the CFPB have crushed community banks and driven more and more banking into the MegaBanks
The notion that Fannie & Freddie leaving conservatorship would raise rates by 100 basis points is not even close to serious, just an insane claim - spreads were actually lower pre-conservatorship
Most of the opposition to ending Fannie/Freddie conservatorships is coming from entities that view the conservatorships as their avenue to robbing the taxpayer
Some career news - will result in less time on social media - White House Office of Management and Budget Announces Incoming Senior Appointees – The White House whitehouse.gov/briefings-sta…
What stopped Fannie & Freddie from exiting conservatorship in 2020-21 was a pandemic, election & Supreme Court case, it had nothing to do with being “too complex” or “difficult” - it’s actually quite straightforward
One of the more disappointing aspects of Fannie/Freddie conservatorships is the degree to which so many DC insiders believe agencies outright ignoring the law is a completely normal and fine outcome #Lawless
The degree to which Biden-Harris Fannie/Freddie policy has been driven by former BlackRock executives, with BlackRock being the biggest beneficiary, is just obscene, if not predictable
Those arguing that Fannie/Freddie exit from conservatorship will raise mortgage rates are essentially arguing that said exit reduces Wall Street’s ability to steal from the taxpayer
New: The spending freeze has set off a scramble in the mortgage industry, amid confusion over whether FHA loans and Ginnie securities are included.
“There is widespread panic in the housing world right now,” an industry leader said.
subscriber.politicopro.com/a…
The longer Fannie/Freddie are in conservatorship, the more likely Congress uses G-fee adds-on’s as budget off-sets, which would be passed along to borrowers
Truly stunning how little the Biden administration seems to understand housing markets, almost everything they’ve proposed increases demand, ultimately doing little for housing affordability
I’ve worked in Congress, I’ve run an agency…special interests have, on average, far more influence at agencies, Chevon deference enables agencies to ignore Congress, often to the benefit of special interests
Mortgages were center of the 2008 financial crisis, Fannie/Freddie were at center of 2008 crisis, yet former Fannie/Freddie executives working at CFPB, for almost a decade, illegally exempted Fannie/Freddie loans from Dodd-Frank mortgage rules - sounds fairly corrupt to me
Any guarantee created by Congress for Fannie/Freddie MBS would have a fee attached & that fee would be passed along to borrowers, so let’s stop pretending a govt guarantee helps borrowers, it helps Wall Street
Honestly it’s just bizarre to see some of the architects of Obama & Biden’s disastrous mortgage policies lecture the rest of us about mortgage costs - like arsonists complaining about fire
Shouldn’t the public be able to know how much of CFPB settlements go to the lawyers & third party groups, & how much actually goes to victims? #AuditCFPB
Regular reminder, there is NO govt guarantee of GSE debt today, as their charters & HERA make crystal clear, anyone suggesting otherwise is confused, or lying & potentially committing securities fraud
If you ever want to know how Treasury views its positions in Fannie/Freddie, it’s right there in the Treasury Dept financial statement - value of warrants are rounding error compared to senior preferred
Strikes me as weird that a body of academic work (Public Choice), a core component of which is industry capture/influence over legislation/regulation gets coded as “right wing”
I appreciate when someone calls Fannie & Freddie the big remaining item from the 2008 crisis needing to be fixed, but the reality is that we didn’t really fix much of anything related to the 2008 crisis
Fact Sheet: President Donald J. Trump Reins in Independent Agencies to Restore a Government that Answers to the American People – The White House whitehouse.gov/fact-sheets/2…
As Chief Statistician of the United States, I congratulate @RealEJAntoni and look forward to working with him to strengthen the integrity of our federal statistical system
Same people who said 2017 TCJA would crash housing mkt & said not rescuing servicers in 2020 would crash housing mkt, now say letting GSEs exit conservatorship would crash housing mkt…starting to notice a pattern here
I so wish an exit from conservatorship would fully end implied guarantee behind GSEs, but there’s zero chance of that actually being true, complete BS argument against exit
An odd aspect of working on Fannie/Freddie policy is that you regularly get to see 1) highly paid Wall Streeters argue for socialism, and 2) progressives defend corporate duopolies
As someone who has worked both as a Senate legislative Committee staffer & as an agency head/staff, the assertion that Congress isn’t capable enough to make policy, relative to agencies, is a deeply ignorant assertion
Over the years, the bank regulators & the SEC have made numerous harmful & outright stupid decisions in their treatment of agency MBS, none of those are a barrier to GSE exit from conservatorship
Instead of eliminating filibuster, we should actually raise it to like 80, along with 5 year sunset on all legislation- that way only broadly supported policies become law = less conflict
GSE exit from conservatorship is not reform, but existing law, so what should Congress do, start with:
1) time limit on conservatorships
2) ‘33 Act coverage
3) chartering authority
4) FHFA -> independent board
5) mission reg back to HUD
6) income limits instead of loan limits
Seems a bit hypocritical for Biden Treasury to suggest FHFA sent a report to FSOC when the Biden Treasury inherited an ongoing FSOC review of Fannie/Freddie, which they then abandoned
As I discuss in my recent book, the net worth sweep of Fannie and Freddie was clearly inconsistent with responsibilities of a conservator amazon.com/Shelter-Storm-Mor…
This part is fake, there was no “lost steam” - there was a pandemic and an election, at no point did anyone involved express concern over complexity finance.yahoo.com/news/us-tr…
One, among many things, that increased my cynicism, is that I had begun an investigation of Wall St underwriters, who may have cost Fannie/Freddie billions, when I left Biden Admin shut down investigation & tried to fire career staff working on it