Another reason why The Batman works better is because it feels realistic. His parents being flawed people is something that I can buy. On the other hand, Superman makes it too cartoonish, especially with egregious harem joke, which is part of the reason why it doesn't work
Let’s talk about the “secrets of the father” reveals in The Batman and Superman (2025)
Both of these ideas are about taking the meta-textual issues with the characters and pinning the blame on an in-text aspect away from the character themselves, so they can try to separate…