Stable Yield Rankings: Week 1 (originally posted on Medium)
I have been diligent about taking profits over the last six months as the crypto market has soared to new all-time highs. I have rotated profits into a wide range of lower-risk opportunities to ensure that I am able to continue to grow my crypto portfolio even if we crest into a longer bear market. Now that I have capital parked in a bunch of different corners of the ecosystem, I wanted to start tracking how well these opportunities are performing. I took stock of each position on December 10th and will be diligently monitoring performance and sharing results each week, along with commentary on how I’m feeling about the performance given the risk/reward profile.
Week 1 Leaderboard
The performance of each product from 12/10–12/17 is shown in the image below. Some things to note about how I’m measuring ROI:
☑️ Starting values for each product were captured on 12/10 (I have different amounts in each product)
☑️ Current values were captured on 12/17 just before drafting this post
☑️ Gains have been re-invested into the same product in all cases except for Adrena Protocol (I’m already overweight here so didn’t want to add further)
Observation 1: Perps LPs are leading the way
The four perpetuals LPs are the best performing yield products over the last week, which is to be expected with the market up over the last week and the underlying LP tokens each having > 50% exposure to blue chip crypto assets like BTC, ETH, and SOL. If the market were down significantly, these would likely be at the bottom of the list (though downside risk is mitigated by fee sharing).
@AdrenaProtocol is the best performing of the four, which makes sense given that Adrena offers 100% fee share to duration locked stakers of ALP and duration locked stakers of their governance token, ADX. They also offer ADX rewards for duration locked stakers. I was also a contributor to their Genesis Pool, so that generates additional rewards.
@flashtrade is the second best performing product, which did surprise me because the fee share is 70% (lower than ALP and in line with JLP) and I’m not taking on extra risk like I’m doing with JLP Multiply. I suspect this will correct over time, but it’s possible that fee share is just more lucrative due to lower TVL in the LP.
JLP Multiply on
@KaminoFinance is still no slouch in 3rd, returning 2.74% of the original position value in 7 days, about 0.6% better than just holding JLP.
Observation 2: Incentivized Liquidity Pools are tough to beat
The best performing stable yield in my portfolio is via the USDC-USDS liquidity pool on Kamino. This pool is currently receiving 200,000 USDS and 2,000 RAY per week, for a combined boosted APY of 25.19%. These rewards won’t last forever, so this is not a completely set-and-forget position, but as long as rewards are this good, this is a no-brainer place to park USDC/USDS due to unbeatable risk/reward (stable LPs are probably the safest place to park stablecoins).
Interestingly, the PYUSD-USDC pool is not performing quite as well, returning only 0.38% yield this week compared to 0.57% for the above-mentioned USDC-USDS pool.
Observation 3: Lending aggregators aren’t clearly winning
I have capital parked in two protocols that claim to help users take advantage of the highest lending yields across the Solana DeFi ecosystem (
@uselulo and
@DeFiCarrot). After one week, Lulo has a slight lead (0.38% yield) over Kamino Lend (0.36% yield) and Carrot (0.33% yield). I was expecting Lulo and Carrot to clearly outperform Kamino Lend, so it’s interesting to see how close things are.
One reason Lulo is probably outperforming is because I have mostly PYUSD and USDS deployed, which have higher lending yields, while Carrot’s portfolio is 95% USDC (only 15% of which is in Kamino JLP).
One week is hardly enough time to make any clear judgments, but if Lulo/Carrot don’t clearly outperform Kamino JLP Lend, you could argue that it’s not smart to take on an extra layer of smart contract risk parking funds in those places if it’s not yielding significantly better returns (especially when Kamino also yields Kamino points for future airdrops of
$KMNO).
Observation 4: Elemental is the winning hedge fund, but all are underperforming expected returns
Elemental Fund and Neutral are the 2nd and 3rd best performing USDC products on my list. However, this is a bit underwhelming considering
@elementaldefi markets a consistent 40% APY,
@TradeNeutral boasted a 100+% APY when I added funds last week, and
@HyperliquidX HLP boasted 90+% APY when I added last week. Both Hyperliquid and Neutral showed losses earlier in the week, so the strategies clearly weren't working well over this time period. It’ll be interesting to see if this shifts more favorable over time.
Observation 5: Does Perena earn yield?
@perena is the newest stablecoin product on Solana and offers a range of stable pools for users. Their founder claimed that pools are earning 35% APY, but I see no evidence of this when viewing my positions on the product, so until that is clarified, this is a big fat zero. They just announced they are revamping their UX to make yield easier to discern, so I'm excited to see that change coming up.
I hope this is helpful analysis for folks who are looking to deploy stablecoins to earn some additional yield. I'll report back again in a week to see how things have adjusted. Cheers!